Evaluation

Evaluation

Please see below for reflection paper rubric.

Poster Rubric

Poster & Presentation 
  Excellent Work
10 pts
Good Work
8 pts
Fair
6 pts
Needs improvement
4 pts
Focus on Topic Content Knowledge 
Excellent Work

The poster includes all information relevant to the topic. The poster is creative, clear and concise. At least five examples/facts are included. The student had all 
information gained through diligent research required for the assignment. 
Good Work

Poster includes all relevant information; however, it is not well-organized or easily understood. Three to four examples/facts are included. 
Fair

Does not have all of the relevant information. There is not enough information presented. Information is presented in an unorganized fashion and may be hard to understand. One to two examples/facts are included. 
Needs improvement

The poster is lacking in elements required. There are many gaps in information presented and facts presented are inaccurate. Confusing. 
Work quality/effort 
Excellent Work

The work done exceeds all expectations and shows that the group is proud of their work. Includes 5 NEAT illustrations or color pictures. Text is clear, neat and straight 
Good Work

The work was done with good effort that shows what the group is capable of. It is evident that time was put into this poster and presentation. Includes 4 NEAT illustrations or color pictures. Text is clear, neat and straight but too tiny for presentation. 
Fair

Work is done with fair effort, but the quality is still not what group is capable of. It is evident that the work was rushed. Includes 3 NEAT illustrations or pictures. All images are black and white. Text is to small, messy or crooked. 
Needs improvement

Work is done with little effort, quality is not what the group is capable of. It is evident that the work was rushed and little time was spent on the final product. Work is incomplete. Includes 0 - 2 illustrations or pictures. All images are black and white. Text is illegible and crooked/messy and tiny. 
Creativity 
Excellent Work

Eye catching. Great use of colors, texture, shapes, and spacing on poster. Creativity is shown to in every area on the poster. Writing is easy to read. 
Good Work

Contains groups own ideas. Lots of colors, shapes, and appealing design. Shows group spent time creating an artistic piece. 
Fair

Not very appealing. Limited use of creative materials. Not alot of color/shapes/design. Most of the drawings/writing is group's own ideas. 
Needs improvement

Lacks original creativity. Not good use of space on poster. Messy. Lacks color, texture. 
Format/presentation
Excellent Work

Poster is of exceptional quality and presentation. Nothing hanging or falling off. Submitted on time. 
Good Work

Poster is correct size, clean and neatly displayed. No items falling off. Submitted on due date. 
Fair

Poster is damaged, poorly presented. Poster was possibly submitted 1 day later than original due date. Some items possibly falling off. 
Needs improvement

Not on required poster paper and/or submitted 2 days late. Pieces/items falling or hanging off. 
Voice 
Excellent Work

Students' voices were loud and clear. Information was easy to understand 
Good Work

Voices are good with minimal gaps in flow of information 
Fair

Voices are acceptable - many gaps in flow of information or times voices could not be understood by all. 
Needs improvement

Students did not speak in a tone that could be heard by all students - too soft. Information too hard to understand. 

 

(iRubric)

 

Reflection Paper Rubric

Criterion 
  Poor
80 pts
Fair
90 pts
Good
100 pts
Content & Development 
50 pts
Poor

- Content is incomplete.
- Major points are not clear and /or persuasive. 
Fair

- Content is not comprehensive and /or persuasive.
- Major points are addressed, but not well supported. 
- Content is inconsistent with regard to purpose and clarity of thought. 
Good

- Content is comprehensive, accurate, and persuasive.
- Major points are stated clearly and are well supported. .
- Content and purpose of the writing are clear. 
Organization & Structure 
20 pts
Poor

- Organization and structure detract from the message of the writer.
- Paragraph is disjointed and lack transition of thoughts. 
Fair

- Structure of the paragraph is not easy to follow. 
- Paragraph transitions need improvement. 
Good

- Structure of the paragraph is clear and easy to follow. 

Format 
10 pts

12 point font, single-spaced, at least one page in length

Poor

- Paper lacks many elements of correct formattting.

- Paragrpah is inadequate/excessive in length. 
Fair

- Paper follows most guidelines.

- Paper is over/ under word length. 
Good

- Paper follows designated guidelines.

- Paper is the appropriate length as described for the assignment. 
Grammar, Punctuation & Spelling 
20 pts
Poor

- Paper contains numerous grammatical, punctuation, and spelling errors.
- Language uses jargon or conversational tone. 
Fair

- Paper contains few grammatical, punctuation and spelling errors.
- Language lacks clarity or includes the use of some jargon or conversational tone. 
Good

- Rules of grammar, usage, and punctuation are followed; spelling is correct.
- Language is clear and precise; sentences display consistently strong, varied structure. 

Finish line